Pay Raise Not Enough to Save Termination Clause: Lessons from Chowanetz v. Ivor Forest Products Ltd.
Brynna Hambly
Even a well-drafted termination clause may not protect an employer if the contract behind it is unenforceable.
In Chowanetz v. Ivor Forest Products Ltd., 2026 BCSC 1760 (“Chowanetz”), the employer, a wood products manufacturer with a plant in Chilliwack, moved its staff onto written contracts in 2024. Under the new contract, Mr. Chowanetz, a moulder technician, would receive only his minimum entitlements under B.C.’s Employment Standards Act, plus one additional week of pay if his employment was terminated. The additional week was conditional on signing a full and final release.
Any contract is only binding (in part) if something is offered in exchange for something of value. When an employee is first hired, the offer of employment and compensation to do the work, in exchange for the employee’s promise to perform the work typically serves as the consideration for an employment agreement. However, when an employer changes an existing contract in its favour, or asks an employee who previously did not have a written employment agreement to sign one, the employer must provide the employee something new in return.
In Chowanetz, the employee did not challenge the wording of the new termination clause itself. Rather, he argued that he had received nothing new or additional for signing on to the new contractual terms and that the contract failed for a lack of fresh consideration. The Court agreed, finding that the new agreement lacked fresh consideration, and awarded the employee six months’ pay in lieu of notice.
Three arguments, none successful
The employer had argued that it provided three different forms of fresh consideration:
-
A raise from $35.00 to $38.50 per hour
-
An RRSP match program, and
-
Bonus eligibility
The Court disagreed that all of these constituted valid fresh consideration. The original offer letter the employee signed had already promised annual wage reviews against the local market, which the employer had skipped for three years. As a result, the Court found that the wage increase merely fulfilled an existing obligation rather than providing a new benefit.
The RRSP match and bonus eligibility also failed as fresh consideration, as neither one was contemplated anew in the 2024 contract, and the contract’s entire agreement clause excluded anything outside its terms. The RRSP matching had been promised before the contract was signed.
The Court would not allow the employer to rely on the contract to limit the employee’s termination entitlements while simultaneously relying on benefits that the same contract left out.
Comments on the duty to mitigate: a high bar for employers
The decision also highlights how hard it is for an employer to prove failure to mitigate. The employee in this case didn’t apply for a single job for six months after he was terminated. The Court said his efforts fell short. In Evans v. Teamsters Local Union No. 31, 2008 SCC 20, the Supreme Court of Canada found that the employer had to prove two things, including that:
-
the employee’s efforts were unreasonable; and
-
the comparable work was available.
In this case, the employer, Ivor, had not produced any evidence of moulder technician jobs, so the employee’s damages weren’t reduced for a failure to mitigate.
Key takeaways
For employers introducing new written employment agreements to existing employees, Chowanetz reinforces the importance of providing some form of fresh consideration that the employee has not already been promised or provided. Before relying on a raise as fresh consideration, employers should review existing offer letters or agreements for pre-existing commitments relating to wage reviews and in general.
To allege failure to mitigate, an employer needs evidence that comparable jobs were actually available, not just evidence that the employee’s search was weak. The decision also serves as a reminder that establishing a failure to mitigate requires more than demonstrating an employee’s inadequate job search efforts. Employers must also provide evidence that comparable employment opportunities were available.
Employees asked to sign a new agreement during employment should first obtain legal advice before proceeding, because a termination clause signed without fresh consideration is not likely to be binding, if tested!


